Not so fast

Daily Herald editorial

Before Minnesota lawmakers finishes their rush to replace teacher tenure with a so-called merit-based evaluation system, they ought to step back and ask whether all the pieces are in place to make a new system work. We fear that those foundational pieces are from ready.

Ever since No Child Left Behind and other student performance measurements became the norm, there has been an accompanying cry for schools to retain teachers based on their skill rather than on how long they have held their jobs. On the face of things, it seems simple to say that schools which must make layoffs should choose from the best teachers, rather than from the least senior. The trouble is that no one — not in Minnesota, not anywhere — has devised a means for determining how to rank teachers’ skills. Student achievement test are not a valid measure, because a host of factors that are outside teachers’ control affects achievement. Kids who live in poverty will generally not perform as well on standardized tests, or learn as quickly, as do children from more affluent families, to name just one common element. The luck of the draw could, in many ways, determine how well teachers appear to perform and, thus, their employability.

Nor is there any underlying incentive for schools to rank teacher skill higher than teacher cost when making layoff decisions. As with skill evaluations, no system has ever been devised to accurately measure and reward school districts based on the quality of education they deliver. Rather, devotion to quality is mostly dependent on the internal dedication of a school’s administrators and teachers, meaning that the virtue of quality will always be pitted against the implacable adversary of cost control. Sometimes, cost control will win out, which would tend to put experienced (and thus higher-paid) teachers at risk.

Clearly, trying to graft a new system of teacher evaluations onto the existing structure of public education is going to be full of problems — problems which we see little evidence Minnesota government is yet capable of solving. Keeping and rewarding teachers based on merit is a great idea; it’s not clear that it’ time has yet come.

SportsPlus

Albert Lea

Mower, Waseca Relay for Life joins with Freeborn Co.

News

Trump picks Sen. JD Vance of Ohio, a once-fierce critic turned loyal ally, as his GOP running mate

News

Trump receives enough delegate votes to officially be Republicans’ nominee

Business

SMART to receive grant funding toward facilities in Austin, Waseca

Mower County

13th annual Austin ArtWorks festival to feature Ta-coumba T. Aiken

News

Federal judge dismisses Trump classified documents case over concerns with prosecutor’s appointment

Business

Hormel again named one of 60 Best Companies to Sell For

News

Authorities hunt for clues, but motive of man who tried to assassinate Donald Trump remains elusive

News

Trump is fine, campaign says, after being whisked off stage following apparent gunfire at rally

Mower County

Passing the test: June flood showed successes of mitigation and work left to do

Mower County

Land acquired for future state hunting site

Mower County

Lunchbox Series to present on new flag design, seal

Education

Education: Graduates

Crime, Courts & Emergencies

Convictions: June 24-July 8

Mower County

In Your Community: Mower County Senior Center

Mower County

In Your Community: Duplicate Bridge

News

US inflation cools again, potentially paving way for Fed to cut interest rates soon

News

Sen. Klobuchar says she’s cancer-free but will get radiation as precaution after a spot removal

Mower County

New Matchbox program opening new vistas for theater students

Mower County

3 suffer life threatening injuries in early afternoon crash just outside of Austin

News

Three weeks after heavy rain, Waterville is still recovering from flooding

News

Presidential battle could play role in control of state capitols in several swing states

Mower County

Celebrating the past, advocating for the future

Albert Lea

Ground broken Wednesday in Albert Lea for inclusive playground