Governor’s budget proposal cannot be sustained

Published 8:25 am Wednesday, April 3, 2019

By Doug Loon

Minnesota Chamber of Commerce

Gov. Tim Walz has unveiled his expansive and expensive budget. The impact is crystal clear: Minnesota businesses and all taxpayers would pay billions of dollars in additional taxes to support his budget that totals $90 billion for the next two years, up more than 8 percent over the existing biennium.

Email newsletter signup

We share the goal of investing in the state’s future. But the governor’s budget proposal is simply unaffordable and will impose additional headwinds to investment by private-sector job-creators.

Gov. Tim Walz

The state does not lack in revenue. Minnesota has a $1 billion budget surplus, and budget reserves are at $2.4 billion. State spending will increase four percent in the next two years and another six percent in the following two years without changes by the Legislature. The governor’s budget recommends raising spending by 8.4 percent for the next two years and more than 10 percent the following two years.

Employers will be asked to pay more than $2 billion to fund this spending – as much as the amount in the state’s rainy day fund.

The governor says Minnesota businesses benefited from the 2017 federal tax reform, justifying his proposal to disproportionately raise business taxes to grow state government. Facts say otherwise. Individual taxpayers received a majority of the federal tax relief, and Minnesota already imposes a high cost of doing business. The federal tax changes capping the deductibility of state and local taxes will make Minnesota’s higher tax rates even more of a competitive concern.

What’s the alternative? A more competitive tax structure that lets employers invest in their companies, employees and communities. Targeted spending that brings a greater sense of value and accountability for public services and programs.

Of all the tax proposals in the governor’s budget, the gas tax has generated the most attention. Investing more in roads and bridges is indeed essential, but a 20-cent, or 70-percent, increase would make Minnesota’s gas tax the fourth highest in the nation. With this change, we would be adding another tax to our top 10 list of taxes. We would be making one of the more competitive and affordable taxes we pay one of the highest.  And, when combined with the other tax increases, the proposal is simply too large and expensive. Instead, we recommend diversifying our revenue streams by tapping transportation-related sales taxes.

If the governor’s budget is passed, we will all be on the hook for more than $8 billion in tax increases for the four-year budget cycle. Of that total, $2.8 billion falls directly on business taxpayers. Business taxes are ultimately passed along, resulting in lower wages and benefits for employees, higher costs for consumers, and lower returns to shareholders.

The governor sounds the theme that we must invest in government to better the lives of Minnesotans. We believe a greater priority is to make sure the state provides an opportunity for growth and innovation through the private sector. The pathway toward economic prosperity requires a balanced approach with selective and strategic investments.

Instead of growing government, we should remove government roadblocks to bring efficiencies to government services and work to help ensure affordability for all Minnesotans.