Archived Story

Local officials: Bullying law lacks definition

Published 9:37am Thursday, December 8, 2011

Local officials agree with federal education experts about bullying: Minnesota’s anti-bullying law is weak.

A Department of Education report about 46 states with laws against bullying gives Minnesota the lowest marks because of lack of scope and definitions in its law.

“We could be probably farther ahead,” said Danielle Borgerson-Nesvold, head of Community Against Bullying in Austin.

Minnesota’s 37-word law is the shortest anti-bullying law in the nation. It was passed in 2006 and amended in 2008 to include cyberbullying. It requires school boards to adopt an anti-bullying policy that addresses intimidation and bullying in all forms.

At issue is Minnesota’s lack of policy. Though the idea was to allow local districts control over bullying policies, there is no state mandate to outline how bullying should be handled in Minnesota schools. In addition, Minnesota is one of two states that doesn’t define bullying boundaries, such as when and where a school is responsible for dealing with bullying or even what bullying means.

Rep. Rich Murray, R-Albert Lea, agrees with the federal Department of Education that Minnesota needs a more defined law, but he said the department may not have recognized Minnesota’s current bullying efforts as fully as they deserve.

“I was a little surprised that they had us ranked that low,” Murray said. “There’s been a lot of talk of bullying issues at the state capital this past session. We’ll juts have to address it a little bit more.”

While Murray supports further definition in Minnesota’ s bullying law, he said he wants to be cautious of micro-managing the schools. It’s important to protect the students, he said, but an updated law shouldn’t be overwhelming for school districts to implement.

“There really can’t be much wrong with having good, solid bullying policies,” said Neveln Elementary School Principal Dewey Schara. Schara is part of CAB and has spent years dealing with bullying policy.

The federal report comes amid a growing focus on school bullying in the wake of school violence and high-profile youth suicides.

Minnesota Attorney General Lori Swanson has proposed legislation to strengthen the state law. She said Minnesota needs to set a strong tone that bullying isn’t tolerated.

Austin’s four-page bullying policy is far more specific, breaking down what constitutes bullying and what the consequences are for bullies, whether they be teachers, administrators, staff or students. What’s more, two years ago the Austin Public School board differentiated simple bullying with harassment. While bullying is, in effect, exerting power over someone, harassment is targeting someone because they belong to a specific protected class, such as a race or sexual identity.

Austin educators are looking at proactively combating bullying.

“We’re trying to get to some of those more subtle forms of bullying, like exclusion,” Schara said.

Austin could have a say in legislative bullying policy as well. Borgerson-Nesvold applied to be part of a 15-member Governor’s Task Force on the Prevention of School Bullying, which would advise Gov. Mark Dayton and the Legislature on anti-bullying policy and could have an affect on future anti-bullying law.

“We have to find something that really works,” Borgerson-Nesvold said.

— Amanda Lillie contributed to this report.

Sign in to Comment | Need help commenting? Click here

  • Rhino

    let the kids settle it… too many rules have made society weak in a hole…

    do you honestly think having a law about bullying has changed the bullies??

    do you honestly think spending $20+ grand on scary guy did anything to stop the kid that is a bully?

    do you honestly think changing the wording of a useless law will change a bully from doing what he does?

    If you do you are right up there with the weakest minds…

    Report comment

  • hphd

    Law may work because bullies are insecure people and weak minded. Maybe some punishment would help some.

    Report comment

  • hartman

    It sucks to have a bully mess with you and sorry for the kids who have to deal with that.
    Rhino is right though that no law or scary guy is going to stop it!!
    You have to take matter in to your own hands and get back at them yourselfs in anyway you can.
    Most bullies are chicken inside once you stand up to them.

    Report comment

  • Gatsby

    In response to Rhino:

    Do you think that desegregation laws did nothing to reduce racial prejudice in education?

    Do you think that the Civil Rights Act did nothing to reduce discrimination in employment?

    Do you think that sexual harassment laws did nothing to reduce sexual harassment in the workplace?

    Do you think that Martin Luther King Jr.’s speeches did nothing to reduce racial discrimination?

    If you do, well, you said it…

    Report comment

    • Rhino

      Honestly…. No they really didn’t… Sad to say… But true.

      Report comment

  • formeraustinian

    Rhino you are one negative cat!! I don’t think I’ve ever seen a positive post from you and looking at your moniker I know why…

    Report comment

  • austinbri

    Rhino –

    Let the kids settle it? Well, they settled it in Columbine, CO, didn’t they?

    Great idea, really. You’re a freaking genius.

    Report comment

    • Rhino

      yes they did….

      remember the facts on that… those kids had a list of kids that bullied them/treated them as outcasts… guess those kids wont be doing that anymore huh?

      Report comment

Editor's Picks