Sen. John Marty talks about the Minnesota Health Plan during a presentation at the Mower County Senior Center Wednesday night. - Eric Johnson/photodesk@austindailyherald.com

Health care plan highlighted

Published 8:02am Thursday, November 18, 2010

For State Sen. John Marty, DFL-Minneapolis, health care is no longer a political issue – it is a moral issue.

Marty spoke at a health care presentation sponsored by the Minnesota Universal Health Care Coalition at the Senior Center Wednesday evening.

“Health care ought to be a right,” Marty said. “We have people going bankrupt from lack of health care; we have people dying from lack of health care. It’s a moral issue.”

Click here for the Herald’s free daily news e-mail.

Marty is the chief author of a bill in the State Senate introducing the Minnesota Health Plan, which is a plan that would cover all Minnesotans and all medical issues.

People on hand at Wednesday night's presentation on the Minnesota Health Plan listen as Dr. Brian Yablon, M.D. talks about the problems of the current health coverage system in the U.S. - Eric Johnson/photodesk@austindailyherald.com

“We’re going to cover everything, including dental, including prescription drugs, including mental illness, including chemical dependency,” Marty said during his presentation. “We’re going to cover more people and more things.”

Marty compared the health care plan to services that citizens pay for out of their taxes, like police, fire and road services.

“If you call 911, the police dispatcher won’t ask if you have police insurance,” he said.

The plan would be paid for through premiums based on a person’s ability to pay. However, Marty said, the plan would cost less than current health care costs, in most cases.

Executive Director of the Minnesota Universal Health Care Coalition Amy Lange, R.N., cited Colorado as an example.

Lange said Colorado conducted a study in 2006 weighing health care options and the cost differences and found that a single-payer, universal system would cost approximately $1.4 billion less than any of the other options and would cover more people.

“Colorado didn’t adopt the plan because they thought it was not politically realistic,” Marty said. “Maybe it’s time to start changing what’s politically realistic.”

At the rate the current Minnesota health plan rates are increasing, health care is projected to increase by $20 billion in the next five years, which would exceed the entire state of Minnesota general fund of $17 billion, Marty said.

“Our (current) system is due to fail,” Lange said. “It’s like an umbrella that melts in the rain. If it doesn’t cover you … what’s the point?”

Lange also said if the Minnesota Health Plan is passed through the legislature and signed into law, it would not be affected by the federal health care bill passed earlier this year. The federal bill has a provision saying that a state can opt out of the federal plan if it can provide benefits that are as good and can cover the same amount of people or more.

“This (plan) way exceeds the federal bill,” Lange said.

“We’d all have the same health care that the richest person in the state gets,” Marty said. “It’s the most outrageous thing that constituents don’t get the same health care as public officials.”

  1. biker

    This is exactly what the entire country needs. Health care is a right and it is outrageous that individuals and families cannot afford it in our country. I agree with Representative Marty that this is a moral issue. We are our brother’s keeper and we need to pay for this through our tax system. Everyone pays in based upon their ability to pay. The sooner this is passed the better. I’m not holding my breath however, because the Republicans and their sympathizers will trot out their tired old points,i.e., socialism, freedom, rugged individualism, etc., etc.. instead of solving this horrific situation.

    Report comment

  2. mn_by_fl

    How is this new plan any different from the current Minnesota care? Also this IS what the country is getting Republicans have jst instilled fear within Americans again ABOUT universal health care.

    Report comment

  3. Rick

    If you want good health care you don’t want the government involved. We lived 3 years under Universal Health care and you don’t want it. Part of the reason health care is so expensive in the US is the government payment system for Medicare. Medicare pays such a small portion of a providers bill that they have to raise prices to cover their losses. Thus the cost to everyone else goes up and insurance costs go up. If the government got out of health care the costs would go down to where we could afford insurance for everyone. It wasn’t that many years ago there wasn’t health insurance because we could pay our bills without difficulty.

    Report comment

  4. souptime

    Hormel is a Prime Example of Being able to Pay our Bills (Many of us)with Little to no Problem. Pre-New Plant.
    This here in Austin is a Perfect Example of WHY Health care is Out of Reach for Many.
    .25 cents per year Raise.
    Minus all Deductions.
    .50- 1.00 Per year (Give or Take) in Medical and other Benefit CUTS. (NOT TAXED)
    (This is Nation Wide) Not Just Hormel.
    Multiply this by 20 years and There you have it!
    Republicanomics 101!
    An Unborn Child has a Right to Life? Quality of Life?
    What about ALL People’s Quality of Life????
    Does Not MORAL CHRISTIAN and Caring for Your Fellow Man, Really Make it Hard to See Republicans ARE WRONG HERE!
    Kinda Conflicts with The Republican Party Mantra(Everyone for themselves) and individual Republicans.
    This Healthcare (CRISIS) will only get worse the longer it GETS DELAYED.
    Republicans VOW to Destroy it!
    Tells you who it DOES NOT HELP!

    Report comment

  5. austinbri

    Obamacare isn’t about healthcare…it’s about generating more taxes to pay for crap we don’t need. Pelosi said it best…”We have to sign the health care bill so you can see what’s in it…” I’m a benefit administrator and if you’ve taken the time to read through the details you will realize this IS NOT what the country needs. I am not arguing over whether or not we should all be subsidizing everyone’s health care. We’ve begun the slide into socialism already, so that’s an argument for another day. But our leaders should have taken the time to create a bill that makes sense, rather than shove something down the country’s throat just to get something passed.

    Report comment

  6. souptime

    To bad Any bill,, had to Start health care.
    I Agree It Will Never Please All……
    Every Program That helps the General Public has been called socialism. Old Defense. The Country is Bloated by Defense and many other things as well.
    50% of Americans were on government assisted Health care Before Obamacare was enacted.
    That Ship had Sailed……………………….

    Report comment

  7. Hootch

    Illegal aliens get free health care, remember the kidney transplant lawsuit in Austin 8 years ago.

    Report comment

  8. mn_by_fl

    If you’re interested in health care at all, a must read book is ‘the healing of america’ by t.r. reid. He truly does a thorough job explaining how the worlds weathiest countries excel and fail in terms of health care and why america ACTUALLY doesn’t hit the nail on the head

    Report comment

Editor's Picks